June 6, 2024: Team Fortress 2 now has "Overwhelmingly Negative" recent reviews on Steam, with only 16% of user reviews in the past 30 days (34,419 total) being positive. While overall reviews are still "Very Positive", TF2 has accrued over 1 million reviews in the past 17 years on the platform, making it a hard needle to shift. Original story follows:
I wrote yesterday about the #SaveTF2 movement's , mobilizing once again to pressure Valve into action against Team Fortress 2's rampant bot problem. The latest operation is a two-pronged approach: an —which has been signed and emailed to Valve over 200,000 times—and a public awareness campaign using the #FixTF2 hashtag to show just how rotten with bots TF2 has become. Well, the public certainly seems aware, and on Steam, that awareness is taking a very
public form:
TF2's recent review rating has plummeted to Mostly Negative thanks to a review-bombing surge that, judging from the graph, started hitting just as the #FixTF2 campaign spun up on June 3. The influx of negative reviews is [[link]] so huge—more than 14,000 have hit in the last 24 hours—that it's warped the scale of the chart, rendering any positive sentiment for the game into barely noticeable blue nubs.
Looking at TF2's overall review history, there's never been a window where players have left anywhere near this many negative reviews. If you gingerly mouse over the individual months on the graph, you'll find that not even in 2022—when #SaveTF2 first emerged—was there a period where TF2 received even a tenth as many negative reviews as players have left over the last day.
I might've assumed a healthy number of those reviews were left by players who saw the #FixTF2 posts and wanted to jump on the outrage bandwagon for a laugh, even if they don't have much attachment to the game. But from what I can see by browsing recent reviews, the vast majority are being left by people with dozens of hours of playtime in TF2, if not hundreds, or even thousands. Maybe I should've known better. I mean, it's Team Fortress 2. It's basically an institution.
Valve hasn't yet responded to the latest wave of demands for anti-bot measures. Funnily enough, the Team Fortress 2 official Twitter account hasn't tweeted since it in 2022. If nothing else, the review-bombing leaves a pretty glaring mark. Based on [[link]] what I can glean from Steam review graphs, Team Fortress 2 has a new claim to fame: It's the only Valve game [[link]] to ever drop below a Mixed rating for recent reviews.